• Global Anti-Corruption Practice

Case Detail

In the Matter of Deutsche Bank AG (2019)


Case Details
  • Case Name
  • In the Matter of Deutsche Bank AG (2019)
  • Date Filed
  • 08/22/2019
  • Enforcement Agency
  • SEC
  • Foreign Official
  • Unnamed government officials.
  • Date of Conduct
  • 2006 to 2014
  • Nature of Business
  • Deutsche Bank is a global financial services company headquartered in Germany. Deutsche maintains publicly traded securities on the NYSE which are registered with the SEC pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Exchange Act. Deutsche Bank is an international corporation and is a holding company for its subsidiaries.
  • Influence to be Obtained
  • According to the SEC, Deutsche Bank violated the books-and-records and internal accounting controls provisions of the FCPA when its Asia-Pacific region’s offices engaged in efforts to hire relatives of potential clients to gain their business.  The potential clients were largely state-owned entities with employees who are considered “foreign officials” by the FCPA and Deutsche Bank’s own Global Anti-Corruption Policy.

    According the SEC, Deutsche Bank utilized a client referral hiring program in which the bank would hire client referrals—oftentimes family members of clients—with the aim of “generat[ing] business” for the bank.  The bank allegedly did so in the Asia-Pacific region and in Russia.  Those that were hired through this process “bypassed [the bank’s] highly competitive and merit-based hiring process” and many of whom “were less qualitied than those” that were hired through the typical process.  In providing referral hires an advantage in the hiring process, the SEC alleged that Deutsche Bank hoped to gain favor with clients and potential clients who were foreign government officials.

    Further, according to the SEC, Deutsche Bank failed to implement a system to ensure it complied with its internal policy prohibiting the hiring of referral candidates affiliated with clients.  Deutsche Bank also allegedly failed to ring-fence those it hired through this process from deals in which those hires’ family members were “key decision maker[s]” hoping to capitalize on their relationship.

    Even after implementing a hiring policy in 2010 for the Asia-Pacific region disallowing referral hires from clients or potential clients, the SEC claims that certain senior Deutsche Bank employees failed to adhere to the policy.  In one instance, the allegedly bank hired a “prohibited candidate” through its joint venture who had previously been rejected as a “high[] FCPA” risk given that the bank had “pending business” with the state-owned entity with which the hire was affiliated.  This hire was made at the request of a state-owned-entity client’s chairman who was the father of the hire.  Despite the hire’s alleged lack of qualifications and poor interview performance, Deutsche Bank’s JV hired her and took steps to ensure her position on the transaction with her father’s entity.  Additionally, to appear compliant with the internal policy, the SEC alleges that Deutsche Bank employees in this region fabricated information to obscure similarly unqualified hires who were affiliated with or referred by state owned clients or potential clients.  Similarly, other unqualified referrals were hired at the request of chairmen and chairwomen of state-owned companies and government officials.

  • Enforcement
  • On August 22, 2019, the SEC settled its enforcement action against Deutsche Bank, taking into consideration Deutsche Bank’s remedial efforts, which included self-disclosure of facts arising from its internal investigation, regular updates, and “enhancements” to its internal controls, anti-corruption programs, hiring practices, and auditing of the referral hire program.  Deutsche Bank was also required to pay disgorgement of about $10.7 million, prejudgment interest of about $3 million, and a $3 million civil penalty.
  • Amount of the Value
  • Not stated.
  • Amount of Business Related to Payment
  • $10,485,900
  • Intermediary
  • Not stated.
  • Citizenship of Parent Entity
  • Germany
  • Total Sanction
  • $ 16,178,850
  • Compliance Monitor
  • No
  • Reporting Requirements
  • No
  • Case is Pending?
  • No
  • Total Combined Monetary Sanction
  • $ 16,178,850
Defendants

Deutsche Bank

  • Citation
  • In the Matter of Deutsche Bank AG, Admin. Proc. File No. 3-19373 (Aug. 22, 2019)
  • Date Filed
  • 08/22/2019
  • Filed Under Seal
  • No
  • Date Case Was Unsealed
  • 01/03/2020
  • FCPA Statutory Provision
    • Books-and-Records
    • Internal Controls
  • Other Statutory Provision
  • None.
  • Disposition
  • Cease-and-Desist Order
  • Defendant Jurisdictional Basis
  • Issuer
  • Defendant's Citizenship
  • Germany
You may share a link to this page on any of the sites listed below:
Material on www.shearman.com is general information and should not be construed as legal advice. Contacting us by email does not create a lawyer-client relationship unless and until we have agreed to handle a particular matter. Please do not convey to us any information you regard as confidential unless and until a formal lawyer-client relationship has been established, as any information we receive from you prior to such time will not be confidential.
Accept Cancel